Find Error in mechanical engineering example problem using column analogy method.

I have an example problem of a loaded ring solved using the column analogy method. I have been able to reproduce the problem in Excel and get the same results as the example. However, when I change the loading to a simpler case I do not get the expected symmetric solution. i.e. T1 = T2 the bending moment should be symmetric. Looking for the error in the Excel spreadsheet or the math.

Column analogy ( from google)

[url removed, login to view]

[url removed, login to view]~ce474/Docs/[url removed, login to view]

Skills: Engineering, Mechanical Engineering

See more: using google spreadsheet, spreadsheet engineering, mechanical engineering com, google spreadsheet example, find the solution to, find mechanical

About the Employer:
( 131 reviews ) Bonita Springs, United States

Project ID: #10752296

6 freelancers are bidding on average $176 for this job


A proposal has not yet been provided

$147 USD in 3 days
(33 Reviews)

I am Mechatronics Engineer. I have done my MS in Design & Manufacturing Engineering. My Expertise are Concept designing, product designing, mechanical designing, manufacturing drawings, AutoCAD, CAD/CAM, Pro E, NX, Sol More

$200 USD in 3 days
(31 Reviews)
$155 USD in 3 days
(32 Reviews)
shahzadk7861 me...... masters student of mechanical engineering here... i can do this

$111 USD in 3 days
(6 Reviews)

Dear I am a professional at CAD/CAM/CAE who specialize 3D modeling/rendering, mechanical design, manufacturing design,product design, FEA for engineering problems and the 2D engineering drawing using SolidWorks,Auto More

$50 USD in 2 days
(6 Reviews)

Sound knowledge and a vigilant mind enable me to utilize my abilities in such a way that pleases my clients and satisfies all their needs. I'm one of the best freelancers in this platform and my enthusiasm will help me More

$222 USD in 2 days
(0 Reviews)

Hi How are you? By profession, I am a mechanical engineer and I can sort out your problem. It's not a difficult task but it needs proper study of task sheet. I will make you happy by my work. Inbox Me with more det More

$222 USD in 4 days
(0 Reviews)